Stephen Gately Stephen Gately funeral: Mournful pride fills Dublin streets for final farewell
whoyg2054 | 20 October, 2009 21:19
Before the hit singles and record deals, before the sell-out tours and worldwide fame, Stephen Gately was an ordinary man from Dublin. He belonged to the city. Yesterday the city gathered to say goodbye to one of its best-loved sons.
From the early hours of the morning, the mourners appeared. Many were fans, wrapped in Irish flags and Boyzone scarves, pressed against the police barriers that lined the roads of grey terraced cottages in Dublin's North Strand. Some were Dubliners who came because they felt a kinship forged in the streets of their shared upbringing. Some were locals who knew Gately's family and emerged from their front doors before breakfast with cups of tea and lit cigarettes, plumes of tobacco smoke indistinguishable from the clouds of breath exhaled in the early morning chill.
"He was one of us, you know?" said Angela Dowling, a 44-year-old mother of two who came out into her front garden at 9am still in her pyjamas. Her neat, red-brick house overlooks the St Laurence O'Toole Roman Catholic church where Gately was baptised. Thirty-three years later, it seemed far too early for Mrs Dowling to be witnessing his funeral. Gately's death from pulmonary oedema while on holiday in Mallorca with his civil partner, Andrew Cowles, sent ripples of shock through a community that loved him without question.
Again and again, you hear him spoken of pearl jewelry as "an ordinary Dub" – the affectionate nickname given to the city's residents – because although Gately travelled the world, he never forgot where he came from. His parents, Margaret and Martin, a former painter and decorator, still live in the North Strand; when Gately tried to buy his mother a bigger house in a better part of town, she refused to move. It is a close-knit, working class community and looks after its own: the day before Gately's funeral, a group of residents cleaned the area around the church, weeding, picking up litter and hosing down the streets.
"They could have had the funeral in London or New York or Los Angeles," said Jimmy, a 50-year-old roadie. "But they chose to have it here. It is a traditional thing for Irish people to come out of their houses and be respectful: the more people that come out for a funeral, the better it is for the family."
And, just like Jimmy said, by 10.30am the streets surrounding the grey-flint church were filled with crowds standing five and more deep on the pavements. There was a strange sense of sadness mixed with expectation, as if no one could quite decide whether it was primarily a funeral or a celebrity event.
As the church bells rang, sleek cars with black-tinted windows started to pull up outside. A trickle of famous faces emerged into the unseasonal sunlight, sporting sunglasses and serious expressions to be surreally greeted by cheers and whoops. The loudest welcome was reserved for members of the boyband Westlife and Louis Walsh, the Boyzone manager and X-Factor judge, who last week described Gately as his "best friend".
Jason Donovan took a few seconds to read the messages stapled to cellophaned bunches of flowers. Former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern arrived without ceremony, walking up the street and shaking hands with passers-by.
"The Gately family is part of this community," he said. "Stephen is one of the heroes here. We're proud of him and it's a great tragedy. I've just been in to see his parents. It's been a tough week, but they're on good form. They've taken comfort and support from the turnout."
As the 550 mourners filed into the church, people piled into biwa pearl neighbours' houses and hung out of the windows brandishing digital cameras. Lynne Deakin, 23, had travelled from Wolverhampton with her mother, Pat, and slept overnight on the pavement. In the small hours, when the four remaining members of Boyzone emerged from an overnight vigil next to Gately's coffin, they gave the Deakins their sleeping bags so that they would not get too cold.
"That was so sweet and unexpected," says Lynne, eyes shaded by the rim of a black trilby embroidered with the years of Gately's birth and death, 1976-2009. "They're broken men but they're doing Stephen proud today."
When the Boyzone band members arrived, dressed in black suits and red ties, a sudden quiet descended. Their devastation was clear: Ronan Keating, the lead singer, was pale-faced and trembling. There were no smiles, no acknowledgement of the crowd.
The 90-minute service was relayed through loudspeakers, the words of the prayers delivered by Fr Declan Blake occasionally swallowed up by traffic noise. Otherwise, there was silence, punctuated only by the comforting murmur of several hundred voices reciting a liturgy they knew by heart. When Ronan Keating sang the hymn "In This Life", his voice powerful and lilting in spite of his obvious grief, the fans outside began to akoya pearl weep, women clutching balled-up tissues to their eyes, mascara half-streaked down their cheeks. But it was the eulogy, delivered by all four remaining bandmates – Keating, Keith Duffy, Shane Lynch and Mikey Graham – that delivered the biggest emotional punch.
"It is with a heavy heart and great sadness that I say the world has lost one of its greatest stars," said Keating, his words echoing against the stone and stained glass. "We have lost a brother. I have lost my wingman." Then he broke down, his voice audibly cracking across the tinniness of the loudspeaker. We could hear his tears and ragged breaths and could sense the shattered fragments of his grief. The crowd broke into spontaneous applause, willing him on. After a few moments, he started again: "He will live on in our songs and whenever us four are together, his spirit will be alive. But it will never be the same."
At 1.30pm, the coffin was carried out of St Laurence's on the shoulders of Gately's bandmates and placed in the hearse that would take him on to the Glasnevin cemetery. His parents followed, their faces blurred with grief as they walked numbly out into the afternoon light.
From the early hours of the morning, the mourners appeared. Many were fans, wrapped in Irish flags and Boyzone scarves, pressed against the police barriers that lined the roads of grey terraced cottages in Dublin's North Strand. Some were Dubliners who came because they felt a kinship forged in the streets of their shared upbringing. Some were locals who knew Gately's family and emerged from their front doors before breakfast with cups of tea and lit cigarettes, plumes of tobacco smoke indistinguishable from the clouds of breath exhaled in the early morning chill.
"He was one of us, you know?" said Angela Dowling, a 44-year-old mother of two who came out into her front garden at 9am still in her pyjamas. Her neat, red-brick house overlooks the St Laurence O'Toole Roman Catholic church where Gately was baptised. Thirty-three years later, it seemed far too early for Mrs Dowling to be witnessing his funeral. Gately's death from pulmonary oedema while on holiday in Mallorca with his civil partner, Andrew Cowles, sent ripples of shock through a community that loved him without question.
Again and again, you hear him spoken of pearl jewelry as "an ordinary Dub" – the affectionate nickname given to the city's residents – because although Gately travelled the world, he never forgot where he came from. His parents, Margaret and Martin, a former painter and decorator, still live in the North Strand; when Gately tried to buy his mother a bigger house in a better part of town, she refused to move. It is a close-knit, working class community and looks after its own: the day before Gately's funeral, a group of residents cleaned the area around the church, weeding, picking up litter and hosing down the streets.
"They could have had the funeral in London or New York or Los Angeles," said Jimmy, a 50-year-old roadie. "But they chose to have it here. It is a traditional thing for Irish people to come out of their houses and be respectful: the more people that come out for a funeral, the better it is for the family."
And, just like Jimmy said, by 10.30am the streets surrounding the grey-flint church were filled with crowds standing five and more deep on the pavements. There was a strange sense of sadness mixed with expectation, as if no one could quite decide whether it was primarily a funeral or a celebrity event.
As the church bells rang, sleek cars with black-tinted windows started to pull up outside. A trickle of famous faces emerged into the unseasonal sunlight, sporting sunglasses and serious expressions to be surreally greeted by cheers and whoops. The loudest welcome was reserved for members of the boyband Westlife and Louis Walsh, the Boyzone manager and X-Factor judge, who last week described Gately as his "best friend".
Jason Donovan took a few seconds to read the messages stapled to cellophaned bunches of flowers. Former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern arrived without ceremony, walking up the street and shaking hands with passers-by.
"The Gately family is part of this community," he said. "Stephen is one of the heroes here. We're proud of him and it's a great tragedy. I've just been in to see his parents. It's been a tough week, but they're on good form. They've taken comfort and support from the turnout."
As the 550 mourners filed into the church, people piled into biwa pearl neighbours' houses and hung out of the windows brandishing digital cameras. Lynne Deakin, 23, had travelled from Wolverhampton with her mother, Pat, and slept overnight on the pavement. In the small hours, when the four remaining members of Boyzone emerged from an overnight vigil next to Gately's coffin, they gave the Deakins their sleeping bags so that they would not get too cold.
"That was so sweet and unexpected," says Lynne, eyes shaded by the rim of a black trilby embroidered with the years of Gately's birth and death, 1976-2009. "They're broken men but they're doing Stephen proud today."
When the Boyzone band members arrived, dressed in black suits and red ties, a sudden quiet descended. Their devastation was clear: Ronan Keating, the lead singer, was pale-faced and trembling. There were no smiles, no acknowledgement of the crowd.
The 90-minute service was relayed through loudspeakers, the words of the prayers delivered by Fr Declan Blake occasionally swallowed up by traffic noise. Otherwise, there was silence, punctuated only by the comforting murmur of several hundred voices reciting a liturgy they knew by heart. When Ronan Keating sang the hymn "In This Life", his voice powerful and lilting in spite of his obvious grief, the fans outside began to akoya pearl weep, women clutching balled-up tissues to their eyes, mascara half-streaked down their cheeks. But it was the eulogy, delivered by all four remaining bandmates – Keating, Keith Duffy, Shane Lynch and Mikey Graham – that delivered the biggest emotional punch.
"It is with a heavy heart and great sadness that I say the world has lost one of its greatest stars," said Keating, his words echoing against the stone and stained glass. "We have lost a brother. I have lost my wingman." Then he broke down, his voice audibly cracking across the tinniness of the loudspeaker. We could hear his tears and ragged breaths and could sense the shattered fragments of his grief. The crowd broke into spontaneous applause, willing him on. After a few moments, he started again: "He will live on in our songs and whenever us four are together, his spirit will be alive. But it will never be the same."
At 1.30pm, the coffin was carried out of St Laurence's on the shoulders of Gately's bandmates and placed in the hearse that would take him on to the Glasnevin cemetery. His parents followed, their faces blurred with grief as they walked numbly out into the afternoon light.
General |
Permalink |
Add comment |
Trackbacks (0)
Crisis over claim that jails 'duped' inspectors by moving inmates(2)
whoyg2054 | 20 October, 2009 21:16
Unions complain the massive apparatus charged with running the country's jails – the National Offender Management Service staffed by 4,000 civil servants – drowns the service's employees in bureaucracy, with the result that they are continuously focused on hitting targets at the expense of everything else. There are unsubstantiated claims that mandatory drug testing figures are being doctored and that regime activities are being exaggerated, in order to obtain positive inspection results. This, some argue, is what inevitably happens in a "target culture".
"The alleged transfer out of prisoners before an inspection is pearl jewelry clearly regrettable but is understandable given the pressure that prisons are under to produce excellent results, inspection after inspection after audit," said Harry Fletcher, assistant general secretary of the probation union, Napo. Fletcher called for an independent review into the use of targets by the prison service, claiming it has "far too much centralised, repetitive bureaucracy".
Questions will inevitably be asked about whether other prisons may have been swapping inmates to achieve better inspection results. Prisoner support groups point out that Wandsworth, Europe's largest prison which can hold more than 1,500 inmates, is considered one of the country's best run jails. They say if it could happen there, where else?
The annual report of the prison's independent monitoring board (IMB), published this month, pays tribute to the hard work of its former governor, Ian Mulholland, who has recently been promoted within the prison service. The IMB declared Wandsworth had "moved from being a hard-nosed repository to an institution where staff have pride in coming to work and treating prisoners fairly and with respect".
Mulholland's opposite number at Pentonville, Nick Leader, who has also just been promoted, is considered a progressive governor, too, despite having to manage an institution that was described by its IMB report in 2007 as suffering "endemic squalor and poverty of regime which ought to be a matter of deep shame to government in 21st-century Britain." Both men will inevitably now face questions as to what they knew about the recent transfer of prisoners between their jails.
The publication of Owers' two reports could not come at a biwa pearl worse time for the service. A record prison population has led to chronic overcrowding while budget constraints have resulted in prisoners being locked up in their cells for longer. Unions warn such actions will lead to a rise in disturbances. Paul Tidball, governor of the Prison Governors Assocation, recently said: "For prisons to become less effective in reducing offending is tragic enough, and against the interests of society and the taxpayer, but the potential catastrophe of widespread disorder resulting from foolhardy cuts takes the debate to another level."
His warning comes amid heightened concerns about security at some of the country's seemingly most secure jails. This year alone, a prisoner escaped from Pentonville by concealing himself under a van while two inmates swapped identities at Brixton, allowing one to flee. Another prisoner disappeared in Holloway for a whole weekend by hiding in a cupboard, while a convicted offender was let out of a prison van leaving Feltham by accomplices, who had arranged his escape by mobile phone. In addition, a visitor was shot dead in the car park outside Wandsworth prison during the summer.
Security inside the prisons is also being questioned. The trade in drugs and mobile phones is said to be endemic, while the Serious and Organised Crime Agency has warned criminal gang bosses are running their empires from behind bars. Corrupt practices by a small number of prison staff raise repeated concerns about the service's ability to investigate its employees.
Given such pressures, scrutiny is paramount, say experts. "The integrity of akoya pearl the prison service and the independence of our prisons inspectorate are respected worldwide, so any action that could lead to prisoners being used as pawns in a game to undermine these institutions must be thoroughly investigated," said Juliet Lyon, director of the Prison Reform Trust.
Some observers believe the widely respected Owers has become frustrated by the amount of attention the prison service pays to her reports. This is unlikely to be a concern come Tuesday.
"The alleged transfer out of prisoners before an inspection is pearl jewelry clearly regrettable but is understandable given the pressure that prisons are under to produce excellent results, inspection after inspection after audit," said Harry Fletcher, assistant general secretary of the probation union, Napo. Fletcher called for an independent review into the use of targets by the prison service, claiming it has "far too much centralised, repetitive bureaucracy".
Questions will inevitably be asked about whether other prisons may have been swapping inmates to achieve better inspection results. Prisoner support groups point out that Wandsworth, Europe's largest prison which can hold more than 1,500 inmates, is considered one of the country's best run jails. They say if it could happen there, where else?
The annual report of the prison's independent monitoring board (IMB), published this month, pays tribute to the hard work of its former governor, Ian Mulholland, who has recently been promoted within the prison service. The IMB declared Wandsworth had "moved from being a hard-nosed repository to an institution where staff have pride in coming to work and treating prisoners fairly and with respect".
Mulholland's opposite number at Pentonville, Nick Leader, who has also just been promoted, is considered a progressive governor, too, despite having to manage an institution that was described by its IMB report in 2007 as suffering "endemic squalor and poverty of regime which ought to be a matter of deep shame to government in 21st-century Britain." Both men will inevitably now face questions as to what they knew about the recent transfer of prisoners between their jails.
The publication of Owers' two reports could not come at a biwa pearl worse time for the service. A record prison population has led to chronic overcrowding while budget constraints have resulted in prisoners being locked up in their cells for longer. Unions warn such actions will lead to a rise in disturbances. Paul Tidball, governor of the Prison Governors Assocation, recently said: "For prisons to become less effective in reducing offending is tragic enough, and against the interests of society and the taxpayer, but the potential catastrophe of widespread disorder resulting from foolhardy cuts takes the debate to another level."
His warning comes amid heightened concerns about security at some of the country's seemingly most secure jails. This year alone, a prisoner escaped from Pentonville by concealing himself under a van while two inmates swapped identities at Brixton, allowing one to flee. Another prisoner disappeared in Holloway for a whole weekend by hiding in a cupboard, while a convicted offender was let out of a prison van leaving Feltham by accomplices, who had arranged his escape by mobile phone. In addition, a visitor was shot dead in the car park outside Wandsworth prison during the summer.
Security inside the prisons is also being questioned. The trade in drugs and mobile phones is said to be endemic, while the Serious and Organised Crime Agency has warned criminal gang bosses are running their empires from behind bars. Corrupt practices by a small number of prison staff raise repeated concerns about the service's ability to investigate its employees.
Given such pressures, scrutiny is paramount, say experts. "The integrity of akoya pearl the prison service and the independence of our prisons inspectorate are respected worldwide, so any action that could lead to prisoners being used as pawns in a game to undermine these institutions must be thoroughly investigated," said Juliet Lyon, director of the Prison Reform Trust.
Some observers believe the widely respected Owers has become frustrated by the amount of attention the prison service pays to her reports. This is unlikely to be a concern come Tuesday.
General |
Permalink |
Add comment |
Trackbacks (0)
How 'ghosting' threatens to plunge UK jails into fresh crisis(1)
whoyg2054 | 20 October, 2009 21:13
Seasoned lags say they are on the "Magic Roundabout". Others residing at Her Majesty's Pleasure complain about being "on tour with the National". But most prisoners simply refer to it as "ghosting" – the shuttling of difficult inmates around the country's jails.
For decades ghosting has been a common practice within the prison service, albeit one that has outraged prisoner support groups. Its strength lies in its simplicity. By constantly moving the most obstinate, often dangerous, prisoners around the system, they have less time to cause havoc and spread their web of influence. "We don't let their arses stay long enough in one place to cause disruption," was the succinct analysis of one senior prison officer.
One prisoner, Gary Nelson, described at one of his many trials as one of "the most violent and dangerous men to walk the streets of Britain", is believed to hold the dubious record for being the country's most ghosted prisoner, having been moved to 33 jails in four years.
Recently, however, ghosting has become something of a dirty word. An official report into disturbances at Harmondsworth immigration detention centre declared that the practice "unsettles the individual detainee" and warned it could disrupt medical treatment and the legal process. Academics have slated it as an "intimidation tactic".
But what really did for ghosting was its expense. With swingeing budget cuts and chronic overcrowding, prisons can no longer afford to keep empty cells, sometimes for pearl jewelry several weeks at a time, on the off-chance they will be called on to take problem inmates.
This Tuesday, however, the practice will come under scrutiny, with potentially explosive results. Two separate reports by the chief inspector of prisons, Anne Owers, will examine claims that two of Britain's largest jails, Wandsworth and Pentonville, ghosted difficult prisoners between them as recently as May and June of this year. What makes Owers' reports required reading is the apparent motivation for the alleged transfers.
Both prisons are being investigated for allegedly swapping their most problematic inmates to keep them out of sight of independent inspectors, in a bid to ensure they received positive assessments in their reports. It is alleged that log books suggest prisoners were removed from one prison shortly before inspectors arrived and were returned almost immediately after they left.
If true, the claims threaten to have seismic implications for the prison service and the way it is independently monitored. They are also likely to trigger a toxic row between prison staff and the Ministry of Justice over the best way to run the country's jails.
The signs from on high suggest all involved are clear about the gravity of the allegations. The justice secretary, Jack Straw, who has launched an official inquiry into the claims, which is due to report later this month, has declared it is "neither policy nor acceptable practice temporarily to move prisoners during inspections".
The inquiry, being led by a former prison governor, was launched after Owers apparently received a tip-off from prison service insiders. It is examining who, if anyone, authorised the transfers, how many prisoners were involved and for how long it went on.
Sources familiar with the situation believe charges of biwa pearl gross professional misconduct are likely to be filed against staff at both prisons soon after the inquiry's findings are published. Any disciplinary hearings, which would be conducted by Michael Spurr, one of the most senior directors in the prison service, could result in staff being removed from their posts or demoted.
But such is the sensitivity over what is involved that there is a complete news blackout on the inquiry's progress or indeed any pending disciplinary action. Straw simply says: "The investigation is due to report in October, at which time I will make a further statement."
Adding a further, troubling dimenson to the situation is the tragic story of Christopher Wardally. During the time of the alleged transfers, Wardally was a suicidal 25-year-old prisoner serving four years for robbery. Although he was not considered a difficult prisoner – and was not one of those allegedly transferred to evade the scrutiny of the inspectors – he still ended up being shuttled between Wandsworth and Pentonville, for reasons that are unclear. After being transferred back to Pentonville, where he had previously attempted to take his life, he was returned to Wandsworth where a day later he was found dead, hanging in his cell. An inquest has yet to determine the cause of death.
It is no surprise, then, that some in the prison service predict the eventual outcome from the mounting number of inquiries, inquests, investigations, disciplinary hearings and official reports into what happened at Pentonville and Wandsworth will be "akin to another Strangeways", a reference to the Manchester prison's riots of 1990 that led to the Woolf inquiry and ushered in sweeping changes to the prison regime.
Woolf addressed prison overcrowding, stretched resources and prisoners' living conditions – all issues that penal experts agree remain pertinent today. But the latest row to akoya pearl engulf the prison service has also raised questions about the pressures public sector staff feel under to meet government targets.
Prison governors are privately highly critical of the number of inspections and audits they must undergo every year. One governor of a large London prison said his institution had been subject to 15 audits or inspections during the past three-and-a-half years. Senior prison staff claim they are under tremendous pressure to ensure that the audits and inspections of their jails are positive. Much is at stake: a negative inspection can lead to the removal of a governor and the jail being demoted in the prison service performance league tables. At a time of low morale, this can have a further debilitating effect on staff.
For decades ghosting has been a common practice within the prison service, albeit one that has outraged prisoner support groups. Its strength lies in its simplicity. By constantly moving the most obstinate, often dangerous, prisoners around the system, they have less time to cause havoc and spread their web of influence. "We don't let their arses stay long enough in one place to cause disruption," was the succinct analysis of one senior prison officer.
One prisoner, Gary Nelson, described at one of his many trials as one of "the most violent and dangerous men to walk the streets of Britain", is believed to hold the dubious record for being the country's most ghosted prisoner, having been moved to 33 jails in four years.
Recently, however, ghosting has become something of a dirty word. An official report into disturbances at Harmondsworth immigration detention centre declared that the practice "unsettles the individual detainee" and warned it could disrupt medical treatment and the legal process. Academics have slated it as an "intimidation tactic".
But what really did for ghosting was its expense. With swingeing budget cuts and chronic overcrowding, prisons can no longer afford to keep empty cells, sometimes for pearl jewelry several weeks at a time, on the off-chance they will be called on to take problem inmates.
This Tuesday, however, the practice will come under scrutiny, with potentially explosive results. Two separate reports by the chief inspector of prisons, Anne Owers, will examine claims that two of Britain's largest jails, Wandsworth and Pentonville, ghosted difficult prisoners between them as recently as May and June of this year. What makes Owers' reports required reading is the apparent motivation for the alleged transfers.
Both prisons are being investigated for allegedly swapping their most problematic inmates to keep them out of sight of independent inspectors, in a bid to ensure they received positive assessments in their reports. It is alleged that log books suggest prisoners were removed from one prison shortly before inspectors arrived and were returned almost immediately after they left.
If true, the claims threaten to have seismic implications for the prison service and the way it is independently monitored. They are also likely to trigger a toxic row between prison staff and the Ministry of Justice over the best way to run the country's jails.
The signs from on high suggest all involved are clear about the gravity of the allegations. The justice secretary, Jack Straw, who has launched an official inquiry into the claims, which is due to report later this month, has declared it is "neither policy nor acceptable practice temporarily to move prisoners during inspections".
The inquiry, being led by a former prison governor, was launched after Owers apparently received a tip-off from prison service insiders. It is examining who, if anyone, authorised the transfers, how many prisoners were involved and for how long it went on.
Sources familiar with the situation believe charges of biwa pearl gross professional misconduct are likely to be filed against staff at both prisons soon after the inquiry's findings are published. Any disciplinary hearings, which would be conducted by Michael Spurr, one of the most senior directors in the prison service, could result in staff being removed from their posts or demoted.
But such is the sensitivity over what is involved that there is a complete news blackout on the inquiry's progress or indeed any pending disciplinary action. Straw simply says: "The investigation is due to report in October, at which time I will make a further statement."
Adding a further, troubling dimenson to the situation is the tragic story of Christopher Wardally. During the time of the alleged transfers, Wardally was a suicidal 25-year-old prisoner serving four years for robbery. Although he was not considered a difficult prisoner – and was not one of those allegedly transferred to evade the scrutiny of the inspectors – he still ended up being shuttled between Wandsworth and Pentonville, for reasons that are unclear. After being transferred back to Pentonville, where he had previously attempted to take his life, he was returned to Wandsworth where a day later he was found dead, hanging in his cell. An inquest has yet to determine the cause of death.
It is no surprise, then, that some in the prison service predict the eventual outcome from the mounting number of inquiries, inquests, investigations, disciplinary hearings and official reports into what happened at Pentonville and Wandsworth will be "akin to another Strangeways", a reference to the Manchester prison's riots of 1990 that led to the Woolf inquiry and ushered in sweeping changes to the prison regime.
Woolf addressed prison overcrowding, stretched resources and prisoners' living conditions – all issues that penal experts agree remain pertinent today. But the latest row to akoya pearl engulf the prison service has also raised questions about the pressures public sector staff feel under to meet government targets.
Prison governors are privately highly critical of the number of inspections and audits they must undergo every year. One governor of a large London prison said his institution had been subject to 15 audits or inspections during the past three-and-a-half years. Senior prison staff claim they are under tremendous pressure to ensure that the audits and inspections of their jails are positive. Much is at stake: a negative inspection can lead to the removal of a governor and the jail being demoted in the prison service performance league tables. At a time of low morale, this can have a further debilitating effect on staff.
General |
Permalink |
Add comment |
Trackbacks (0)
Crisis over claim that jails 'duped' inspectors by moving inmates(2)
whoyg2054 | 20 October, 2009 21:11
But claims the practice has allegedly been employed to remove problem prisoners before inspections is a new and serious development that threatens to plunge the Prison Service into crisis, especially if it triggers further suggestions that the practice is widespread.
Such is the sensitivity over what is involved, there is a complete news blackout on the inquiry's progress. Straw simply says: "The investigation is due to report in October, at which time I will make a further statement."
Adding a further, troubling dimension to the situation is the tragic story of Christopher Wardally. During the time of the alleged transfers, Wardally was a suicidal 25-year-old prisoner serving four years for robbery. Although he was not considered a difficult prisoner – and was not one of those allegedly transferred to evade the scrutiny of the inspectors – he still ended up being shuttled between Wandsworth and Pentonville, for reasons that are unclear.
After being transferred back to Pentonville, a prison where he had previously attempted to take his life, he was returned to Wandsworth, where a day later he was found dead, hanging in his cell. An inquest has yet to determine the cause of death.
It is no surprise, then, that some in the Prison Service predict the eventual outcome from the mounting number of inquiries, inquests, investigations, disciplinary hearings and official reports into what happened at Pentonville and Wandsworth will be "akin to another Strangeways", a reference to the Manchester prison's riots of 1990 that triggered the Woolf inquiry and ushered in sweeping changes to the prison regime.
Woolf's inquiry addressed prison overcrowding, stretched resources and prisoners' living conditions – all issues that penal experts agree remain extremely pertinent today. But the latest row to engulf the prison service has also raised questions about the pressures public-sector staff feel under to meet exacting government targets.
In private, prison governors are highly critical of the pearl jewelry number of inspections and audits they must undergo on an annual basis. One governor of a large London prison said his institution had been subject to 15 audits or inspections during the past three and a half years.
Much is at stake: a negative inspection can lead to the removal of a governor and their jail being demoted in the Prison Service performance league tables. At a time of low morale in the Prison Service, this can have a further debilitating effect on staff.
Unions complain the massive apparatus charged with running the country's jails – the National Offender Management Service, staffed by 4,000 civil servants – drowns the service's employees in bureaucracy, with the result that they are continuously focused on hitting targets at the expense of everything else.
There are unsubstantiated claims that mandatory drug-testing figures are being doctored and that regime activities are being exaggerated, in order to obtain positive inspection results. This, some argue, is what inevitably happens in a "target culture".
"The alleged transfer out of prisoners before an inspection is clearly regrettable but is understandable given the pressure that prisons are under to produce excellent results, inspection after inspection after audit," said Harry Fletcher, assistant general secretary of the probation officers' union, Napo. Fletcher called for an independent review into the use of targets by the Prison Service, claiming it has "far too much centralised, repetitive, bureaucracy".
Questions will inevitably be asked about whether other prisons may have been swapping inmates to achieve better inspection results. Prisoner support groups point out that biwa pearl Wandsworth is considered one of the country's best-run jails. They say if it could happen there, where else?
The annual report of the prison's independent monitoring board (IMB), published this month, pays tribute to the hard work of its former governor, Ian Mulholland, who has recently been promoted within the Prison Service. The IMB declared Wandsworth had "moved from being a hard-nosed repository to an institution where staff have pride in coming to work and treating prisoners fairly and with respect".
Mulholland's opposite number at Pentonville, Nick Leader, who has also just been promoted, is considered a progressive, highly popular governor, too, despite taking over an institution that was described by its IMB report in 2007 as suffering "endemic squalor and poverty of regime which ought to be a matter of deep shame to government in 21st-century Britain". Both men will inevitably now face questions as to what they knew about the recent transfer of prisoners between their jails.
The imminent publication of Owers's reports and the inquiry's findings come at a tense time for the Prison Service. A record prison population has led to chronic overcrowding within the UK's jails while budget constraints have resulted in prisoners being locked up in their cells for longer. Unions warn such actions will lead to a rise in disturbances within prisons. Paul Tidball, chairman of the Prison Governors Association, recently observed: "For prisons to become less effective in reducing offending is tragic enough, and against the interests of our society and the taxpayer, but the potential catastrophe of widespread disorder resulting from foolhardy cuts takes the debate to another level."
His warning comes amid heightened concerns about security at some of the country's seemingly most secure jails. This year alone, a prisoner escaped from Pentonville by concealing himself under a van while two inmates swapped identities at Brixton, allowing one to flee. Another prisoner disappeared in Holloway for a whole weekend by hiding in a cupboard, while a convicted offender was sprung by accomplices from a prison van leaving Feltham, having arranged for his escape on a mobile phone. In addition, a visitor was shot dead in the car park outside Wandsworth prison during the summer.
Security inside the prisons is also being questioned. The akoya pearl widespread trade in drugs and mobile phones behind bars is said to be endemic, while the Serious and Organised Crime Agency has warned that criminal gang bosses are running their empires from behind bars. Corrupt practices by a small number of prison staff raise repeated concerns about the service's ability to investigate its employees. Islamist prisoners sympathetic to al-Qaeda have been the target, and the cause, of major prison disturbances.
Given such pressures, adequate scrutiny of Britain's jails is paramount, say experts. "The integrity of the prison service and the independence of our prisons inspectorate are respected worldwide, so any action that could lead to prisoners being used as pawns in a game to undermine these institutions must be thoroughly investigated," said Juliet Lyon, director of the Prison Reform Trust.
Straw's statement to the Observer said: "The chief inspector will make her own judgments in her inspection reports on the prisons, due for release shortly, but it is neither policy nor acceptable practice temporarily to move prisoners during inspections."
Some observers believe the widely respected Owers has become frustrated by the amount of attention the prison service pays to her reports. This is unlikely to be a concern come Tuesday.
Such is the sensitivity over what is involved, there is a complete news blackout on the inquiry's progress. Straw simply says: "The investigation is due to report in October, at which time I will make a further statement."
Adding a further, troubling dimension to the situation is the tragic story of Christopher Wardally. During the time of the alleged transfers, Wardally was a suicidal 25-year-old prisoner serving four years for robbery. Although he was not considered a difficult prisoner – and was not one of those allegedly transferred to evade the scrutiny of the inspectors – he still ended up being shuttled between Wandsworth and Pentonville, for reasons that are unclear.
After being transferred back to Pentonville, a prison where he had previously attempted to take his life, he was returned to Wandsworth, where a day later he was found dead, hanging in his cell. An inquest has yet to determine the cause of death.
It is no surprise, then, that some in the Prison Service predict the eventual outcome from the mounting number of inquiries, inquests, investigations, disciplinary hearings and official reports into what happened at Pentonville and Wandsworth will be "akin to another Strangeways", a reference to the Manchester prison's riots of 1990 that triggered the Woolf inquiry and ushered in sweeping changes to the prison regime.
Woolf's inquiry addressed prison overcrowding, stretched resources and prisoners' living conditions – all issues that penal experts agree remain extremely pertinent today. But the latest row to engulf the prison service has also raised questions about the pressures public-sector staff feel under to meet exacting government targets.
In private, prison governors are highly critical of the pearl jewelry number of inspections and audits they must undergo on an annual basis. One governor of a large London prison said his institution had been subject to 15 audits or inspections during the past three and a half years.
Much is at stake: a negative inspection can lead to the removal of a governor and their jail being demoted in the Prison Service performance league tables. At a time of low morale in the Prison Service, this can have a further debilitating effect on staff.
Unions complain the massive apparatus charged with running the country's jails – the National Offender Management Service, staffed by 4,000 civil servants – drowns the service's employees in bureaucracy, with the result that they are continuously focused on hitting targets at the expense of everything else.
There are unsubstantiated claims that mandatory drug-testing figures are being doctored and that regime activities are being exaggerated, in order to obtain positive inspection results. This, some argue, is what inevitably happens in a "target culture".
"The alleged transfer out of prisoners before an inspection is clearly regrettable but is understandable given the pressure that prisons are under to produce excellent results, inspection after inspection after audit," said Harry Fletcher, assistant general secretary of the probation officers' union, Napo. Fletcher called for an independent review into the use of targets by the Prison Service, claiming it has "far too much centralised, repetitive, bureaucracy".
Questions will inevitably be asked about whether other prisons may have been swapping inmates to achieve better inspection results. Prisoner support groups point out that biwa pearl Wandsworth is considered one of the country's best-run jails. They say if it could happen there, where else?
The annual report of the prison's independent monitoring board (IMB), published this month, pays tribute to the hard work of its former governor, Ian Mulholland, who has recently been promoted within the Prison Service. The IMB declared Wandsworth had "moved from being a hard-nosed repository to an institution where staff have pride in coming to work and treating prisoners fairly and with respect".
Mulholland's opposite number at Pentonville, Nick Leader, who has also just been promoted, is considered a progressive, highly popular governor, too, despite taking over an institution that was described by its IMB report in 2007 as suffering "endemic squalor and poverty of regime which ought to be a matter of deep shame to government in 21st-century Britain". Both men will inevitably now face questions as to what they knew about the recent transfer of prisoners between their jails.
The imminent publication of Owers's reports and the inquiry's findings come at a tense time for the Prison Service. A record prison population has led to chronic overcrowding within the UK's jails while budget constraints have resulted in prisoners being locked up in their cells for longer. Unions warn such actions will lead to a rise in disturbances within prisons. Paul Tidball, chairman of the Prison Governors Association, recently observed: "For prisons to become less effective in reducing offending is tragic enough, and against the interests of our society and the taxpayer, but the potential catastrophe of widespread disorder resulting from foolhardy cuts takes the debate to another level."
His warning comes amid heightened concerns about security at some of the country's seemingly most secure jails. This year alone, a prisoner escaped from Pentonville by concealing himself under a van while two inmates swapped identities at Brixton, allowing one to flee. Another prisoner disappeared in Holloway for a whole weekend by hiding in a cupboard, while a convicted offender was sprung by accomplices from a prison van leaving Feltham, having arranged for his escape on a mobile phone. In addition, a visitor was shot dead in the car park outside Wandsworth prison during the summer.
Security inside the prisons is also being questioned. The akoya pearl widespread trade in drugs and mobile phones behind bars is said to be endemic, while the Serious and Organised Crime Agency has warned that criminal gang bosses are running their empires from behind bars. Corrupt practices by a small number of prison staff raise repeated concerns about the service's ability to investigate its employees. Islamist prisoners sympathetic to al-Qaeda have been the target, and the cause, of major prison disturbances.
Given such pressures, adequate scrutiny of Britain's jails is paramount, say experts. "The integrity of the prison service and the independence of our prisons inspectorate are respected worldwide, so any action that could lead to prisoners being used as pawns in a game to undermine these institutions must be thoroughly investigated," said Juliet Lyon, director of the Prison Reform Trust.
Straw's statement to the Observer said: "The chief inspector will make her own judgments in her inspection reports on the prisons, due for release shortly, but it is neither policy nor acceptable practice temporarily to move prisoners during inspections."
Some observers believe the widely respected Owers has become frustrated by the amount of attention the prison service pays to her reports. This is unlikely to be a concern come Tuesday.
General |
Permalink |
Add comment |
Trackbacks (0)
Crisis over claim that jails 'duped' inspectors by moving inmates(1)
whoyg2054 | 20 October, 2009 21:06
Two of Britain's biggest jails are at the centre of an investigation that threatens the careers of senior prison service staff.
The Observer has learned that several high-ranking employees at Wandsworth and Pentonville prisons in London may face disciplinary proceedings following an investigation into allegations that they tried to dupe inspectors to help gain their jails favourable assessments.
The Prison Service launched an investigation after the chief inspector of prisons, Dame Anne Owers, said she had received information the two jails were transferring difficult prisoners before her inspections in an attempt to ensure they received positive reports. The prisons and probation ombudsman, Stephen Shaw, has also expressed concerns about the alleged transfers.
A Prison Service meeting to discuss bringing charges of gross professional misconduct against several staff was held last Tuesday and further developments are expected imminently. Owers is this week expected to make scathing criticisms of the regimes at the two prisons.
The Ministry of Justice yesterday declined to say whether any Prison Service staff had been charged. But in a statement given to the Observer, Jack Straw, the justice secretary, declared it is "neither policy nor acceptable practice temporarily to move prisoners during inspections". There is speculation that pearl jewelry he could be forced to make a statement to the House of Commons about the affair later this month.
Owers first submitted her allegations of suspicious prisoner transfers to the director general of the Prison Service, Phil Wheatley, who launched the investigation. Straw has stipulated that it must examine "who proposed and authorised the transfers; the rationale for the transfers; and the circumstances of the actual transfers themselves and whether those transfers took place in line with policy requirements relating to the well-being of prisoners".
The inquiry is focusing on claims that a small number of the most difficult prisoners were swapped between the two category-B men's jails in May and June of this year. It is alleged that log books suggest prisoners were removed from one prison shortly before inspectors arrived and were then returned almost immediately after they left.
If true, the claims threaten to have seismic implications for the akoya pearl Prison Service and the way it is independently monitored. They are also likely to trigger a toxic row between prison staff and the Ministry of Justice over the best way to run the country's jails.
Many close observers of the penal system have expressed shock at the allegations. The two prisons – both built in the mid-19th century – have won plaudits for attempting to shake off their Victorian pasts, but overcrowding and tightened budgets have led to concerns about their ability to improve further. With a capacity of more than 1,500, Wandsworth is the country's largest prison. Pentonville can hold more than 1,100 prisoners.
On Tuesday, Owers will publish two separate reports into conditions and practices at the two prisons that are likely to trigger a debate about the way the country's jails respond to inspections and the support given the watchdog by the Prison Service.
They are also expected to address allegations that the prisoners were swapped, or "ghosted" as it is known by seasoned inmates. Some prison personnel argue "ghosting" is an effective way of managing disruptive prisoners and helps others make fresh starts. The "dispersal" technique – also known as "the magic roundabout" – was widely used for decades, but has fallen out of favour in recent years.
By constantly moving the most obstinate, often dangerous, prisoners around the system, they have less time to cause havoc and spread their web of influence, runs the thinking.
"We don't let their arses stay long enough in one place to biwa pearl cause disruption," was the succinct analysis of one senior prison officer.
Gary Nelson, described at one of his many trials as one of "the most violent and dangerous men to walk the streets of Britain", is believed to hold the dubious record for being the country's most ghosted prisoner, having been moved to 33 jails over just one four-year period.
Recently, however, ghosting has become something of a dirty word. An official report into disturbances at Harmondsworth immigration detention centre declared that the practice "unsettles the individual detainee" and warned it could disrupt medical treatment and the legal process. Academics have slated it as an "intimidation tactic".
What really did for ghosting was its expense. With swingeing budget cuts and chronic overcrowding, prisons can no longer afford to keep cells empty, sometimes for several weeks at a time, on the off-chance they will be called on to take problem inmates.
The Observer has learned that several high-ranking employees at Wandsworth and Pentonville prisons in London may face disciplinary proceedings following an investigation into allegations that they tried to dupe inspectors to help gain their jails favourable assessments.
The Prison Service launched an investigation after the chief inspector of prisons, Dame Anne Owers, said she had received information the two jails were transferring difficult prisoners before her inspections in an attempt to ensure they received positive reports. The prisons and probation ombudsman, Stephen Shaw, has also expressed concerns about the alleged transfers.
A Prison Service meeting to discuss bringing charges of gross professional misconduct against several staff was held last Tuesday and further developments are expected imminently. Owers is this week expected to make scathing criticisms of the regimes at the two prisons.
The Ministry of Justice yesterday declined to say whether any Prison Service staff had been charged. But in a statement given to the Observer, Jack Straw, the justice secretary, declared it is "neither policy nor acceptable practice temporarily to move prisoners during inspections". There is speculation that pearl jewelry he could be forced to make a statement to the House of Commons about the affair later this month.
Owers first submitted her allegations of suspicious prisoner transfers to the director general of the Prison Service, Phil Wheatley, who launched the investigation. Straw has stipulated that it must examine "who proposed and authorised the transfers; the rationale for the transfers; and the circumstances of the actual transfers themselves and whether those transfers took place in line with policy requirements relating to the well-being of prisoners".
The inquiry is focusing on claims that a small number of the most difficult prisoners were swapped between the two category-B men's jails in May and June of this year. It is alleged that log books suggest prisoners were removed from one prison shortly before inspectors arrived and were then returned almost immediately after they left.
If true, the claims threaten to have seismic implications for the akoya pearl Prison Service and the way it is independently monitored. They are also likely to trigger a toxic row between prison staff and the Ministry of Justice over the best way to run the country's jails.
Many close observers of the penal system have expressed shock at the allegations. The two prisons – both built in the mid-19th century – have won plaudits for attempting to shake off their Victorian pasts, but overcrowding and tightened budgets have led to concerns about their ability to improve further. With a capacity of more than 1,500, Wandsworth is the country's largest prison. Pentonville can hold more than 1,100 prisoners.
On Tuesday, Owers will publish two separate reports into conditions and practices at the two prisons that are likely to trigger a debate about the way the country's jails respond to inspections and the support given the watchdog by the Prison Service.
They are also expected to address allegations that the prisoners were swapped, or "ghosted" as it is known by seasoned inmates. Some prison personnel argue "ghosting" is an effective way of managing disruptive prisoners and helps others make fresh starts. The "dispersal" technique – also known as "the magic roundabout" – was widely used for decades, but has fallen out of favour in recent years.
By constantly moving the most obstinate, often dangerous, prisoners around the system, they have less time to cause havoc and spread their web of influence, runs the thinking.
"We don't let their arses stay long enough in one place to biwa pearl cause disruption," was the succinct analysis of one senior prison officer.
Gary Nelson, described at one of his many trials as one of "the most violent and dangerous men to walk the streets of Britain", is believed to hold the dubious record for being the country's most ghosted prisoner, having been moved to 33 jails over just one four-year period.
Recently, however, ghosting has become something of a dirty word. An official report into disturbances at Harmondsworth immigration detention centre declared that the practice "unsettles the individual detainee" and warned it could disrupt medical treatment and the legal process. Academics have slated it as an "intimidation tactic".
What really did for ghosting was its expense. With swingeing budget cuts and chronic overcrowding, prisons can no longer afford to keep cells empty, sometimes for several weeks at a time, on the off-chance they will be called on to take problem inmates.
General |
Permalink |
Add comment |
Trackbacks (0)
Congratulations!
whoyg2054 | 07 October, 2009 04:51
If you can read this post, it means that the registration process was successful and that you can start blogging
General |
Permalink |
Add comment |
Trackbacks (0)
Menu
search
calendar
| « | July 2010 | » | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | Su |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |||
| 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
| 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 |
| 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 |
| 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | |
recently...
- Stephen Gately Stephen Gately funeral: Mournful pride fills Dublin streets for final farewell
- Crisis over claim that jails 'duped' inspectors by moving inmates(2)
- How 'ghosting' threatens to plunge UK jails into fresh crisis(1)
- Crisis over claim that jails 'duped' inspectors by moving inmates(2)
- Crisis over claim that jails 'duped' inspectors by moving inmates(1)
- Congratulations!